Recently, Times Magazine published a photo essay by Sara Lewkowicz, a graduate student from Ohio. What started as a piece on the stigma of being an ex-convict, turned into a documentation of domestic abuse. Lewkowicz followed around a young couple, Shane and Maggie, in Ohio for a few months.
One night she witnessed violent behavior and began taking photographs. The photos are very powerful and disturbing. There's such a big difference between photographs and words when it comes to documentation, because words don't always sound as bad as pictures look. Words can also be stretched and emotions can sway opinions, but one can't deny something in a photograph. Seeing these photos makes domestic violence seem real and near.
The photo below is one of the most shocking in the collection. It shows Shane attacking Maggie in front of her 2-year-old daughter, Memphis.
She's received a mix of criticism from internet commenters. Her critics argue she should've intervened. To respon, Lewkowicz said, "Allow me to clarify. I am a 5’2″ woman. I am not physically equipped to do what you are suggesting. There were two other adults there who were much larger than I am, and both individuals were too scared to do anything."
This is a very tricky subject that isn't new to photojournalism. War photographers have often received the same criticism. Though I think the only two options in a lot of cases are to not intervene and observe what happens or to not intervene and document what happens. I think what Lewkowicz did was very brave. She did it as an ally to Maggie, the victim, and wasn't doing it for shock value. In fact, the photos were subpoenaed and used to convict Shane.
Photography spans a wide spectrum of utilities, from lighthearted, whimsical vacation pictures to images that evoke strong emotion and document heavy subjects like domestic abuse or other injustices. I think that depsite technological advances, the power of a photograph will never diminish.
A link to the full article on Times' website : http://lightbox.time.com/2013/02/27/photographer-as-witness-a-portrait-of-domestic-violence/#1